Wednesday, June 19, 2019
Home World health authorities plagiarized Monsanto

health authorities plagiarized Monsanto

This document was central to the decision to re-authorize the herbicide in Europe in 2017.

By Stéphane Foucart Posted today at 10h04, updated at 10h20

Time to Reading 5 min.

Subscribers article

Soybean field in Argentina, in 2018.
Soybean field in Argentina, 2018. PABLO AHARONIAN / AFP

The glyphosate assessment report, the cornerstone of the European decision, taken at the end of 2017, to re-authorize the famous herbicide for five years, is a vast plagiarism.

Mandated by the European Union to produce the preliminary glyphosate expertise – more than 4,000 pages – the German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (Bundesinstitut für Risikobewertung, or BfR) copied, often word for word, the Glyphosate registration dossier sent to the European authorities by Monsanto and its industrial allies, gathered within the Glyphosate Task Force (GTF).

In a report commissioned by MEPs and released Tuesday (January 15th), the famous Austrian plagiarism hunter Stefan Weber and the biochemist Helmut Burtscher, associated with the NGO Global 2000, show that the key chapters of the scientific evaluation by BfR are the result of more than 50% plagiarism, and more than 70% copied and glued. According to the two researchers – whose work was reviewed by two specialists in scientific plagiarism before being made public – "It is clear that the adoption by BfR, without critical recession, of biased, incorrect or incomplete information provided by the manufacturers [de glyphosate] influenced the very basis of his assessment " of the dangerousness of the controversial product.

However, it is on the basis of this preliminary assessment that the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) and the experts from the Member States have concluded that glyphosate does not pose a carcinogenic hazard, thus paving the way for its re-authorization. Europe. In March 2015, the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) concluded that glyphosate was "probably carcinogenic".

In September 2017, Global 2000 had already revealed that three sub-chapters of the BfR report had been largely copied and pasted. But the passages examined were limited to only 2.5% of the total report. Mandated by MEPs Anja Hazekamp (European United Left), Maria Noichl (Socialists and Democrats) and Bart Staes (Greens), MM. Weber and Burtscher have this time conducted a comprehensive analysis of the report's sections related to the chronic toxicity and carcinogenicity of the herbicide – more than a thousand pages.

Read also Dangerousness, toxicity, utility: the debate on glyphosate summary under discussion for / against
The "Genotoxicity" chapter of the BfR assessment of glyphosate. The passages highlighted in red are plagiarized from the registration file filed by industrialists, according to two researchers.
The "Genotoxicity" chapter of the BfR assessment of glyphosate. The passages highlighted in red are plagiarized from the registration file filed by industrialists, according to two researchers. Weber & Burtscher

"A false idea of ​​the author"

They further distinguished "Benign copy-pasted" – identical reproduction of abstracts of studies or tables – passages constituting plagiarisms. Plagiarism, explain the authors, is "A fraudulent practice almost always intended to deceive the reader". " It means that (…) the reader has a false idea of ​​the identity of the author, write the two plagiarism hunters. The reader falsely assigns sentences, wordings, data, statistics, synopses, etc., to a named or supposed author, whereas in reality the elements he reads have been collected, organized and written by another author. "


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Must Read

"Carrie" musical in Hamburg: The best production of the Stage School

"Carrie" is pure horror. The first novel by Stephen King made him world famous in 1974. Two years later, "Carrie - Des...

Trump rings election campaign for re-election 2020

Orlando - With a major rally in Florida, US President Donald Trump has ushered in his campaign for 2020. Together with his followers, he...

Is this the best, stupidest deed ever to improve America's talent?

Here's one thing that could literally only work once and then never again. Andy Rowell spoke in favor America's Got Talent claiming that he...

PlayStation games are currently up to 75 percent on offer

E3 is ready and over, but Sony continues to offer a variety of games for sale.The sale runs until June 25th and unfortunately does...

Breakthrough cancer drugs that can attack all tumors are rapidly monitored by the NHS

eEarlier detection and treatment of cancer is a key component of the long-term health care plan. Stevens is expected to report to the NHS Confederation...