Penguins’ Recent Struggles and Roster Questions

The Pittsburgh Penguins, after a promising start to the season, have experienced a period of instability. A recent victory offered a momentary reprieve, but preceded an eight-game stretch without a win. A significant contributing factor to this downturn has been the team’s inability to hold leads, a particularly concerning issue following the trade of their starting goaltender.

This inconsistency has naturally fueled speculation about potential roster shakeups. While the Penguins’ front office hasn’t publicly committed to any specific moves, the possibility of trading established players like Evgeni Malkin and Kristopher Letang has been widely discussed.

However, one player appears untouchable, according to Dany Dubé. Speaking on 98.5 FM, Dubé emphatically stated that Sidney Crosby will not be traded.

“Sidney Crosby isn’t going anywhere.” – Dany Dubé

Crosby’s future in Pittsburgh | “Number 87 isn’t going anywhere” -Dany Dubé https://t.co/sgQdRxOjci

— 98.5 Sports (@985Sports) December 23, 2025

Crosby: An Untouchable Asset

Dubé’s assessment centers on Crosby’s unparalleled importance to the Penguins organization. Considered by many to be the greatest player in franchise history, trading him would be akin to a move that would be unthinkable in today’s NHL. Dubé drew a comparison to the legendary Jean Béliveau, highlighting the historical significance and irreplaceable nature of such a player.

While the NHL landscape has dramatically evolved since Béliveau’s era, the underlying principle remains: some players transcend statistics and become symbols of a franchise. Crosby embodies that for the Penguins.

The recent change in ownership also plays a crucial role. New owners are keenly aware of the need to maintain a strong fan base, and trading Crosby would undoubtedly diminish the team’s appeal and potentially impact attendance. Attracting fans to PPG Paints Arena is paramount for the new ownership group, and Crosby is a major draw.

Ultimately, Dubé believes Crosby holds significant sway over his own destiny. While the Penguins might entertain offers if Crosby explicitly requested a trade, the prevailing sentiment is that the organization desires to retain him for the remainder of his career. His continued high level of play further reinforces this desire.

Do you believe a franchise player should have the final say in trade decisions? And how much weight should ownership place on fan appeal when considering roster moves?

The Penguins face a critical juncture. Balancing the need for immediate improvement with the long-term vision of the franchise will require careful consideration, and Crosby’s future will undoubtedly be central to that process.

Frequently Asked Questions About Sidney Crosby’s Future

Additional NHL News

— Weird stuff.

One of the five times this season Sam Montembeault allowed a goal on the first shot he saw, the goal was in fact scored on a rebound. Except the initial shot Montembeault stopped did not count as a shot. So he gave up a rebound goal on the first shot on goal. Go figure. https://t.co/Z1GrB1QxQJ

— Arpon Basu (@ArponBasu) December 23, 2025

— Interesting stuff.

Jeff Marek: Re Wild: I don’t think Bill Guerin’s done, I still think there’s another shoe to drop here, at least one — Sekeres & Price (12/19)

— NHL Rumor Report (@NHLRumorReport) December 23, 2025

— Well done.

We’re teaming up with Hagens’ Helpers during the World Juniors! For every Team USA win, join us in giving to help neighbors access the food they need. Follow along Dec 26-Jan 5. pic.twitter.com/gRNjF6DqZ0

— Feeding America (@FeedingAmerica) December 22, 2025