Foo Fighters & NIN Drummers: A “Great Fit” Swap 🥁

The Drummer Shuffle: A Timeline of Events

Last July, the music world took note when Ilan Rubin announced his departure from Nine Inch Nails to join the Foo Fighters. This move followed closely after Josh Freese’s exit from the Foo Fighters, a decision that, at the time, lacked a clear public explanation. Shortly thereafter, Nine Inch Nails welcomed Freese back into the fold, a reunion that wasn’t entirely unexpected given his previous tenure with the band from 2005 to 2008. Nine Inch Nails’ swift re-engagement of Freese underscored the logistical benefits of familiarity.

Rubin Sets the Record Straight

Rubin emphasized the lack of orchestration behind the moves. “There is no story, honestly. I think it’s just a very logical thing,” he stated. “There was nothing behind it. And it’s very logical in the sense that Josh played with [Nine Inch Nails] from, I wanna say, ’05 to the end of ’08.” His contract with Nine Inch Nails had a defined end date, and upon its conclusion, the opportunity with the Foo Fighters presented itself as a natural progression.

“As far as I knew, my contract ended on a date. After that, it was, what am I doing next? And when this happened and the opportunity presented itself and it was just an obvious great fit and a great thing for me,” Rubin explained. He made his debut with the Foo Fighters in September, a performance widely celebrated by fans.

The Practicalities of Touring

Rubin highlighted the practical challenges of onboarding a new drummer, particularly for a band like Nine Inch Nails. “As a result of me taking that opportunity, obviously Nine Inch Nails needed a drummer,” he said. “And I would imagine that at this point in time, Trent doesn’t wanna spend however many weeks at a rehearsal studio playing the same songs over and over and over again to break in a new drummer. And aside from that, Josh has already done it before, so it was very logical on that. I mean, why else would you go find somebody else?”

He firmly dismissed the notion of a pre-planned exchange between Foo Fighters’ Dave Grohl and Nine Inch Nails’ Trent Reznor. “So I don’t think there’s anything particularly surprising there. But when the news leaked, ‘cause it did leak, it was kind of billed as this drummer swap. Now that would imply that Trent and Dave were, like, ‘Hey, you know what would be a great idea? Why not?’ Which is the dumbest thing.” He reiterated, “But the dots were obviously connected where there was a switch. But it was certainly not a swap. I left my tenure with Nine Inch Nails to join Foo Fighters. Nine Inch Nails needed a drummer, and the drummer they got was the guy who was no longer with Foo Fighters. And that’s literally what it was.”

Rubin expressed some regret over the public perception of his departure from Nine Inch Nails, clarifying that it wasn’t a casual decision. “The only thing that kind of really bothered me at the time when that news leaked was that it kind of gave the impression that I just kind of said, ‘Well, this came up. I’m outta here. Have fun, guys,’ which was not the case at all. Everyone knew what my commitments were, and I’m a very, very loyal guy and I do what I say I’m gonna do.”

The Aftermath and Ongoing Questions

The circumstances surrounding Josh Freese’s departure from the Foo Fighters remain somewhat ambiguous. Freese himself initially expressed shock and disappointment, stating he was unsure why he was let go. Trent Reznor acknowledged being surprised by Rubin’s move, but quickly saw the opportunity to bring Freese back into the Nine Inch Nails lineup. Reznor emphasized the convenience and efficiency of re-engaging a familiar talent.

More recently, the Foo Fighters characterized Freese’s dismissal as a mutual decision. The band stated the decision was “best for all parties”, though specific details remain undisclosed.

What does this series of events say about the dynamics within major rock bands and the often-complex realities of touring musicians? And how much weight should fans place on the narratives presented by the bands themselves?

Frequently Asked Questions