The Adelaide Crows enter Saturday’s Super Saturday clash against Collingwood not just facing a formidable opponent, but a psychological hurdle that’s plagued them for over a decade. This isn’t simply about a losing record; it’s about a pattern of underperformance against a consistently strong Magpies side, compounded by the pressure of a failed finals campaign and heightened expectations for 2026. The stakes are high as Adelaide attempts to prove last year’s straight-sets exit was an anomaly, not a harbinger of things to come.
- The Hoodoo is Real: Adelaide hasn’t beaten Collingwood at the MCG since 2014, and have won only one of their last 13 encounters overall.
- Pressure Cooker: Triple premiership winner Jack Riewoldt believes Adelaide is under immense scrutiny to demonstrate their legitimacy as a premiership contender.
- Midfield Questions: Concerns linger over Adelaide’s midfield depth and ability to match Collingwood’s physicality, particularly after failing to secure Christian Petracca.
The Crows’ struggles against Collingwood extend beyond simple statistics. The MCG itself looms large, a venue where Adelaide has historically faltered, losing 11 of their last 13 fixtures. This isn’t merely a home-field advantage for Collingwood; it’s a demonstrably difficult environment for Adelaide to perform in. The addition of Cal Ah Chee and Finnbar Maley are positive steps, but the question remains whether these changes are sufficient to address the deeper issues exposed by last year’s disappointing finals series. The failed pursuit of Petracca highlights a clear need for a dynamic midfielder, a void Adelaide hopes to fill internally with the development of players like Josh Rachele.
However, the pressure isn’t solely on Adelaide. While Collingwood remains a highly respected team, questions are emerging about their sustainability. They are the oldest team in the league, relying heavily on experienced players – 10 starters are 30 or older. Their shaky finish to last season and a less-than-convincing win against St Kilda have fueled speculation about a potential decline. The Pies’ reliance on uncontested marks (147 last week, significantly above the league average) raises concerns about their ability to maintain that style against more aggressive, turnover-focused teams like Adelaide.
The Forward Look
This match is a crucial litmus test for both sides. For Adelaide, it’s an opportunity to break the Collingwood curse and silence the doubters. A win would signal a genuine step forward and establish them as legitimate contenders. However, a loss would intensify the scrutiny and raise serious questions about their ability to handle pressure. The key for Adelaide will be disrupting Collingwood’s uncontested game and exploiting their defensive vulnerabilities, particularly given the Pies’ current injury concerns in the backline.
For Collingwood, this game is about reaffirming their status as a top-four team. They need to demonstrate they can still compete at a high level despite their aging roster and address the concerns about their game style. Their ability to generate inside-50s (they were -23 against St Kilda) will be critical. If they can’t win the contested possession battle and create scoring opportunities, the questions about their decline will only grow louder.
Ultimately, Jack Riewoldt’s assessment rings true: the MCG factor is significant. While Adelaide may possess the talent to challenge Collingwood, the unfamiliar surroundings and historical disadvantage give the Magpies a crucial edge. Expect a close contest, but a Collingwood victory appears the most likely outcome, at least for this encounter. The broader season, however, will reveal whether Collingwood can maintain their dominance or if Adelaide can finally overcome their demons and emerge as a genuine premiership threat.
Discover more from Archyworldys
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
